PICK TRACKER: Live Review of Days 1 and 2

Photo Credit: Tim Heitman (USA Today Sports)

It’s time for the second round, where the Minnesota Vikings select at No. 62. Follow along to see how the rest of Day 2 shakes out, and check out our Zone Coverage player profiles for additional info and analytics — just click on the player name to be taken to the page.

Note: The Rank column represents the player’s rank in Arif Hasan’s consensus board.

Tm Pick Ovr Rank Player Pos College Our Thoughts
CLE 1 1 11 Baker Mayfield QB Oklahoma
Great pick; he’s the most accurate QB in the draft at all three levels of the field and set FBS records for passing efficiency
NYG 2 2 1 Saquon Barkley RB Penn State
Not a smart decision from the perspective of positional value, but he’s a demon in the passing game and an electric runner.
NYJ 3 3 8 Sam Darnold QB USC
A prototypical passer that will need time to develop, the Jets get a tough player that checks all the boxes, though will need to work on reducing turnovers. We think Rosen is better.
CLE 4 4 9 Denzel Ward CB Ohio State
Possibly the best CB in the draft, the Browns start rounding out a promising secondary with an instinctive, athletic playmaker. Probably not the best return on draft capital, but still a great player.
DEN 5 5 3 Bradley Chubb EDGE NC State
A player who can rush the passer and stuff the run, Chubb is a consensus top player at a premium position. Landry may have more speed and pass-rush upside, but Chubb can be a star, especially next to Miller
IND 6 6 2 Quenton Nelson OG Notre Dame
The best player in the draft at a position they need to upgrade. Perfect fit, even if the position doesn’t traditionally hold tons of value.
BUF 7 7 29 Josh Allen QB Wyoming
It’s good to be aggressive to grab the quarterback they want, but we think Allen shouldn’t be that QB. His inaccuracy is a killer fault and he’s not amazing under pressure, either.
CHI 8 8 5 Roquan Smith LB Georgia
Instinctive, fast and technically sound, Smith could be the Bears’ answer to Eric Kendricks. A fantastic prospect with minor concerns that should pay dividends.
SFO 9 9 17 Mike McGlinchey OT Notre Dame
A solid tackle in a weak class, McGlinchey won’t need too much coaching up before immediately making an impact on the field to protect Jimmy GQ.
ARI 10 10 4 Josh Rosen QB UCLA
The best pure passer in the draft, Rosen is a heady quarterback that will need more protection than Arizona has to offer, but should provide phenomenal long-term dividends. Our QB1.
MIA 11 11 6 Minkah Fitzpatrick CB/S Alabama
A versatile defensive back that can play a Tyrann Mathieu-type role for Miami, Fitzpatrick should be an immediate boon for the defense. We think the Dolphins should have gone with Lamar Jackson, but Minkah is great.
TAM 12 12 12 Vita Vea DT Washington
The rare pass-rushing nose tackle, Vea offers tremendous athletic upside for a big player while still allowing Tampa to shut down the run. A versatile player that should thrive next to Gerald McCoy.
WAS 13 13 24 Da’Ron Payne DT Alabama
He can stop the run, but there’s an open question about his pass-rush capability. We don’t particularly like him, but the pick makes sense from the perspective of reinforcing a strength for Washington.
NOR 14 14 26 Marcus Davenport EDGE UTSA
Davenport is a superlative athlete in many respects, but it will take some time for him to make an impact and there are other pass-rushers on the board. To give up a two firsts for that seems unwise.
OAK 15 15 45 Kolton Miller OT UCLA
Not a good pick and pretty classic Tom Cable. The best athlete in the draft at any position, but he’s been consistently poor at the actual job of playing offensive tackle. He will have to work on mentality, footwork and upper-body technique.
BAL 16 16 10 Tremaine Edmunds LB Virginia Tech
The youngest player in the draft, Edmunds may end up being the most versatile linebacker in the bunch. He is great pick for value but has a lot of technique coaching ahead of him and is still risky.
LAC 17 17 7 Derwin James S Los Angeles Chargers
A phenomenal pick. The Chargers have needed safety help to work with that talented cornerback corps. He’s great in the box and fluid. Should be an immediate upgrade. Great value pick, too.
GNB 18 18 16 Jaire Alexander CB Green Bay Packers
This is a pretty phenomenal pick for the Packers, unfortunately — Alexander is the most analytics-friendly player in the draft and allowed a 17.7 passer rating when thrown to. Fluid and instinctive, he should help Pettine’s defense immediately.
DAL 19 19 30 Leighton Vander Esch LB Dallas Cowboys
An athletic linebacker who fills a big need, the Cowboys have a phenomenally athletic duo for the long-term. Vander Esch has a lot to work on and needs to prove he’s not a one-year wonder, but he makes sense.
DET 20 20 41 Frank Ragnow OC Detroit Lions
A “late riser,” Ragnow can play guard or center extraordinarily well. This is a good pick for the strongest and most capable center in the draft.
CIN 21 21 34 Billy Price OC/G Ohio State
The Bengals were likely going to select Ragnow if he was there but Price isn’t a bad backup option. A good mover that can play either interior line position, Price offers immediate zone-running upside and good pass protection.
TEN 22 22 22 Rashaan Evans LB Alabama
A solid run-thumper with great instincts, he fits Tennessee’s old-school style of play, though he’s not a slouch in coverage. It’s a solid pick, but nothing spectacular.
NWE 23 23 15 Isaiah Wynn OG Georgia
Aside from Quenton Nelson, Wynn may be the best offensive lineman in the draft and the Patriots grabbing him at 23 is fantastic value at an important position. Smart move; we approve.
CAR 24 24 32 D.J. Moore WR Maryland
A speedy, explosive pass catcher from the same school as Stefon Diggs. Had great success despite shoddy quarterback play. Also dabbles in special teams. Another great weapon for Cam Newton and new OC Norv Turner.
BAL 25 25 54 Hayden Hurst TE South Carolina
A former minor-league baseball player, Hurst enters the league pretty old for a rookie. He doesn’t have tremendous production to make up for that, but he is athletic. We don’t like the pick because he represents extraordinary risk at a non-premium position
ATL 26 26 20 Calvin Ridley WR Alabama
Doubling down on a strength does make some sense and he should be regarded highly, but the Falcons do have some glaring holes that need to be resolved. This pick will be easier to grade once we know the rest of their draft, but it seems unwise right now.
SEA 27 27 64 Rashaad Penny RB San Diego State
Penny is a talented back that was probably underrated by the Consensus Board, but in no way do we think he’s worth a first-round pick for positional, need or pure talent reasons. Seattle often zigs when the league zags, but this is too much.
PIT 28 28 105 Terrell Edmunds S Virginia Tech
The worst pick by far from the consensus board. He’s not particularly large, and plays slower than his tested time. Has agility issues and misses tackles. In the long run, he has potential to be a great run-stuffing safety but for now strikes us a poor pick.
JAX 29 29 28 Taven Bryan DT Florida
In order to succeed, the incredibly explosive and athletic Taven Bryan needs a good coaching environment around him and he should have that in Jacksonville. He’s got a lot of tools but plays without a plan right now. It’s a good value pick given his upside, though one has to question passing up on Lamar Jackson here.
MIN 30 30 33 Mike Hughes CB Central Florida
The pick is a clear signal that the Vikings have some long-term plans at cornerback with Trae Waynes and/or Mackensie Alexander, but it does leave some open questions about their offensive line. Stay tuned to Zone Coverage for more reactions!
NWE 31 31 36 Sony Michel RB Georgia
The Patriots must have cleared his medicals and if so, he’s a fantastic versatile option for their running attack that does allow some room in the passing game, especially in pass protection.
BAL 32 32 21 Lamar Jackson QB Louisville
One of the best picks in the first round in our eyes, the Ravens move up to secure a fifth-year option on the most dynamic quarterback in the draft. Coming out of a pro-style system but with some technical issues to correct, he has the luxury to sit for a while as the Ravens wait out Joe Flacco’s contract.
CLE 1 33  51 Austin Corbett OG Nevada It’s a little surprising to see this pick so early, but Corbett can play all three offensive line positions and has the intelligence to handle line calls. It’s a good value pick for the Browns in general, though not as good as Connor Williams (if the medicals check out)
NYG 2 34  25 Will Hernandez OG  UTEP A fantastic guard that should be a strong fit for what the Vikings want to do, which is apparently run the ball. He’s also a stellar pass protector and that creates a great environment for Eli and a QB to be named later.
CLE 3 35  39 Nick Chubb RB Georgia Chubb is a very good running back, but Cleveland has an acceptable — not great — RB corps without a lot of other help to ease their new quarterback in. If they can plumb the depths of this year’s WR class, they’ll be fine but for now it seems a little suboptimal.
IND 4 36 87 Darius Leonard LB South Carolina State Leonard is not a very good pick. He’s undersized, slow and not physical — losing reps against very low-level competition without getting to the sideline quickly enough to make up for it.
IND 5 37  61 Braden Smith OG Auburn Smith is a great guard that didn’t get enough run as a potential steal in the second round because of how strong the top of the class was. There may be an issue with Connor Williams, so with what was left, he was probably the top guard left. A good, athletic guard with pass protection capability.
TAM 6 38 35 Ronald Jones  RB USC In other years, Jones could have been the top back. He’s more of a slasher, but he’s immensely productive and should help Winston in the passing game.
CHI 7 39 29 James Daniels  OC Iowa This will likely move Whitehair back to guard, but it’s a good way to get Chicago’s running game going again. Though he struggles against strong defensive tackles — of which there is no shortage of in the division — they should end up with a strong interior to counter all the talented defensive lines they’ll see.
DEN 8 40 31 Courtland Sutton  WRF SMU The best jump-ball receiver in the class, Sutton surprised with his excellent agility scores, suggesting that he may be able to do much more than make red zone catches. This rounds out an excellent Broncos receiving corps, though it doesn’t make their offensive line problem can go away.
TEN 9 41  13 Harold Landry EDGE Boston College For the Titans to get the second-best edge player in the draft in the second round who can bend better than any of them. A great pass-rusher that isn’t quite great against the run, he should be a stud for a while if his medicals check out. One of the steals of the draft.
MIA 10 42  46 Mike Gesicki TE Penn State Not a great blocker, but a very good contested-catch player, Miami gets a touchdown threat that makes their receiving corps more dynamic and take on a different flavor now that Jarvis Landry is out and Gesicki is in. And it can’t hurt that he’s an athletic freak.
DET 11 43  59 Kerryon Johnson  RBF  Auburn Kerryon Johnson is a fine running back, and the Lions definitely need help there, but it’s difficult to imagine Johnson being worth a trade up when the other running backs left in the draft are as good or better.
SFO 12 44  67 Dante Pettis WRF Washington Pettis is a great slot player with phenomenal agility. His short-area quickness should allow him to dominate underneath for Jimmy Garappolo while players like Marquise Goodwin stretch the field. It’s a solid pick.
GNB 13 45  67 Josh Jackson  CB Iowa A potential first-round pick, the Packers now have three cornerbacks who have been picked in the first two rounds — all three of whom have first-round pedigree. Mike Pettine should love having the diversity and strength of talent they have across the cornerback corps. Jackson will likely fit in the slot, where his instincts can take over.
KAN 14 46  137 Breeland Speaks  DL3T  Ole Miss Not a great pick. There are good corners on the board and better three-techniques as well. He’s the 137th-ranked player on the consensus big board.
ARI 15 47 44 Christian Kirk  WRS  Texas A&M The Cardinals have needed to revamp their receiver corps for some time, though they may have done better with one of the few offensive lineman left in the draft. This should help Josh Rosen and/or Sam Bradford, but perhaps not as much as a lineman.
LAC 16 48  74 Uchenna Nwosu  EDGE  USC Though it’s not fantastic value per the consensus board, this is still a good pick. It amplifies the budding pass rush in LA and he’s super athletic in a way that should translate to success on the field.
PHI 17 49  40 Dallas Goedert TE South Dakota State A great tight end and a better troll. Good job by Philadelphia to grab Dallas Goedert, the best tight end in the draft by our estimation. He can both block and catch better than almost everyone else in the class.
DAL 18 50  23 Connor Williams  OT Texas A fantastic pick. They will likely move him inside in Dallas and it reinforces an already great offensive line that allows La’el Collins to play on the outside.
CHI 19 51  48 Anthony Miller WRS Memphis A fantastic interior receiver, Miller should complement Allen Robinson well and round out a diverse and explosive receiving corps for Trubisky.
IND 20 52  81 Kemoko Turay EDGE Rutgers More potential than production, Turay has all the physical tools to dominate but hasn’t had a healthy stretch of play since his freshman year of college. It’s a big risk for the second round, so it’s not an ideal pick but he’s a good player.
TAM 21 53  83 M.J. Stewart CB North Carolina While not quite high on our consensus board, Stewart is a very good player that can play on the inside or outside. The Buccaneers need to build out that defense and Stewart slots in well, though he was likely overdrafted.
CIN 22 54  57 Jessie Bates III  S Wake Forest An underrated safety, Kansas City was probably better off going with a corner. Nevertheless, Bates represents a versatile safety that might be the hardest hitter at the position in the draft outside of Derwin James. He has to clean up technique, but KC should be happy
CAR 23 55  52 Donte Jackson  CB LSU Fast, but not particularly large or long — he’s a corner that will thrive in some matchups but not others. His in-game recovery speed is phenomenal and he can pair it with good instincts.
NWE 24 56  89 Duke Dawson  CB Florida An instinctive and incredibly productive corner at Florida, he has some of the best coverage scores of the cornerbacks in the draft, though he’s limited to the slot. Those are starters in today’s NFL, so it makes some sense. It seems odd that Isaiah Oliver is still on the board.
OAK 25 57  163  P.J. Hall  DL3T Sam Houston State Hall is an incredibly exciting player, but this is a terrible value pick. Extremely productive and athletic, but not very technically sound and not completely sure of what’s in front of him
ATL 26 58  37 Isaiah Oliver CB Colorado Long, fairly fast and immensely productive, this is one of the better steals in the draft at a position the Falcons need to shore up
WAS 27 59 14 Derrius Guice  RBF  LSU Best player left on the board and a justifiable pick based on their needs, Washington took advantage of a fall brought on by poor interviews and mysterious off-field concerns.
PIT 28 60  50 James Washington  WRF Oklahoma State A deep threat that needs to work on his hands technique, Washington is certainly an open question. It fits that he goes to Pittsburgh, who have paired Antonio Brown with a slough of athletic receivers with technical issues.
JAX 29 61  60  D.J. Chark  WRF  LSU Another speedster with some technical issues, Chark adds a different element to a receiving corps with underneath receivers Marqise Lee, Dede Westbrook and Rashard Greene and red zone targets Jaelen Strong and Donte Moncrief
MIN 30 62  72 Brian O’Neill  OT  Pittsburgh A raw athlete that only has three years of experience at offensive tackle, O’Neill moves well and has shown a lot of athletic potential. He should fit in perfectly in the zone scheme, but he hasn’t developed consistent good habits. For more on our coverage of Brian O’Neill stay here at Zone Coverage!
TAM 31 63  42 Carlton Davis CB  Auburn The Buccaneers once again choose to shore up the defense with the selection of Carlton Davis to play alongside M.J. Stewart. He’s one of the best corners on the board and can play in multiple spots and systems
IND 32 64 115 Tyquan Lewis EDGE  Ohio State The Colts absolutely need to continue to build up their defense. He could be a five-technique or an edge player, but there were better players for both of those positions — even Rasheem Green can play both positions with more upside.
OAK 1 65  144 Brandon Parker OT North Carolina A&T A great pick for a player who will have time to develop his technique, Parker is a huge athletic tight end that showed significant coachability at the Senior Bowl
NYG 2 66  56 Lorenzo Carter EDGE/LB  Georgia A straight-line athlete that doesn’t showcase a lot of bend or have a lot of production, Carter is a potentially high-upside guy that we see as more fool’s gold than moldable clay.
CLE 3 67  116 Chad Thomas EDGE Miami (FL) An underrated edge prospect that seemingly isn’t going to a place that needs him in Cleveland, this is a case where BPA clashes with need. Because there were some better players that fit Cleveland’s needs, we don’t think this is a great pick but it’s understandable
HOU 4 68 43 Justin Reid  S  Stanford A versatile nickel/safety that should complement Tyrann Mathieu really well. The Texans should have a pleasantly complex defensive setup if they play their cards right.
NYG 5 69  77 B.J. Hill  DL1T  NC State A run-plugger that has pass-rush potential, the Giants are extremely committed to an old-school game that we don’t think is entirely smart overall. That said, Hill is one of the better one-technique tackles in the draft
SFO 6 70 85 Fred Warner  LB BYU An athlete with good coverage capability, San Francisco is probably comfortable
DEN 7 71 82 Royce Freeman  RBF Oregon Probably not quite an optimal pick positionally with C.J. Anderson on the team, Freeman is fundamentally a good back.
NYJ 8 72 62 Nathan Shepherd  DL3T Fort Hays State A small steal; Shepherd is an athletic and coachable tackle that the Jets have the luxury to develop
MIA 9 73  88 Jerome Baker  LB  Ohio State
WAS 10 74  100  Geron Christian  OT  Louisville A polarizing tackle prospect, this allows Washington to play Christian instead of Arie Kouandjio at guard in the short term and maintain long-term leverage in the tackle market
KAN 11 75  79 Derrick Nnadi  DL1T Florida State A run-plugging one-technique that doesn’t have much pass-rush upside, he definitely has value for the Chiefs who need to fill that position. Still, it’s not a high-value position and there are better one-techniques.
PIT 12 76  55 Mason Rudolph QB Oklahoma State He’s not good, but he slots in well as a third-round pick as a developmental backup with good anticipation and accuracy. The Steelers are always looking for a backup QB and in a few years they will look again.
CIN 11 77 47 Sam Hubbard EDGE Ohio State Another third-round, athletic edge player. Who knows if Jordan Willis will turn out, but they continue to round out their depth in the same way the Vikings do with constant mid-round competition
CIN 12 78  69 Malik Jefferson LB  Texas It’s been longer than a decade since they’ve had a true athlete at linebacker. Though Jefferson needs to work on his diagnosis, he adds speed to a notoriously slow linebacker corps
SEA 13 79  73 Rasheem Green  DL5T  USC He could play the Red Bryant role in their old, 2011-2012 scheme but more likely will immediately fill in for Michael Bennett. The pick makes sense
HOU 14 80 70 Martinas Rankin  OT Mississippi State
DAL 15 81 78 Michael Gallup  WR  Colorado State It’s good for Dallas to finally add a receiving option. Though he’s not quite the contested-catch receiver that Bryant was, he does add that element back into their receiving game, though he needs to add weight.
DET 16 82  280 Tracy Walker S Louisiana-Lafayette
BAL 17 83  68 Orlando Brown  OT  Oklahoma It’s cool that Brown ends up going to his father’s old team, and this is about where a player with such a split in film and athleticism scores should go. Smart pick.
LAC 18 84  157 Justin Jones  DL1T  NC State He definitely fulfills a role on their defensive line and probably rounds them out, but with Harrison Phillips on the board it seems like an odd selection
CAR 19 85  103 Rashaan Gaulden  CB Tennessee
BAL 20 86  63 Mark Andrews  TE Oklahoma An immensely productive tight end that is probably better than their first-round tight end. Though the fact that they drafted two tight ends is baffling.
OAK 21 87  66 Arden Key  EDGE  LSU The pick makes sense as a means of bolstering their pass-rush, but there are athletes just as good left on the board with fewer questions. Then again, his production is unmatched.
CAR 22 88 148 Oren Burks  LB  Vanderbilt A super-athlete that will need to demonstrate the instincts he didn’t show at Vanderbilt. Paired with Blake Martinez, this could be a phenomenal hit or a meek disaster
LAR 23 89 136 Joseph Noteboom  OT  TCU Not a great pick for value, but there are very few serviceable tackles left. Noteboom has developmental upside and an immediate athletic return. He needs to sit and work on his base, however
ATL 24 90 121 Deadrin Senate  DL3T South Florida  Overdrafted
NOR 25 91  112 Tre’Quan Smith  WR Central Florida  Overdrafted
PIT 26 92 75 Chukwuma Okorafor  OT Western Michigan  Smart pick
JAX 27 93  38 Ronnie Harrison  S Alabama  Really smart pick
TAM 28 94  120 Alex Cappa OT Humboldt State Good pick
SFO 29 95 154 Tarvarius Moore S Southern Miss Analytic gem. Just because he’s low on the consensus board doesn’t mean it’s a poor pick
BUF 30 96  46 Harrison Phillips DL1T  Stanford Really smart pick
ARI 31 97  108 Mason Cole OC Michigan Makes sense, though he shouldn’t play center with how often his snaps go awry
HOU 32 98  210 Jordan Akins TE Central Florida Old
DEN 33 99  117 Isaac Yiadom CB Boston College Not a phenomenal pick given his production on the field and other corners available, but understandable
KAN 34 100  124 Dorian O’Daniel  LB  Clemson  A good coverage player and a solid pick

 

 

Green Bay Packers
What Type Of Quarterback the Packers Will Look For In the Draft?
By Wendell Ferreira - Apr 7, 2023
Green Bay Packers
Blake Freeland Could Be A Good Day 2 Fit for Green Bay
By Chris Callaway - Apr 5, 2023
Green Bay Packers

The Packers Can't Miss Out On Top TE Talents In the Draft

Photo Credit: Tim Heitman (USA Today Sports)

With the departure of Robert Tonyan to the Chicago Bears, and Marcedes Lewis‘ future more than likely tied to that of Aaron Rodgers, the tight end situation […]

Continue Reading